Shiloh book how many pages

Insightfully, Marty concludes that "nothing is as simple as you guess - not right or wrong, not Judd Travers, not even me or this dog. Out Of Stock Email me when back in stock.

You are about to leave our Partner site. Please complete your order now! You are about to leave our Parents site. Are you sure you want to leave? By Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Trade Paperback Hardcover eBook. About The Book. Reading Group Guide. By clicking 'Sign me up' I acknowledge that I have read and agree to the privacy policy and terms of use. Must redeem within 90 days. See full terms and conditions and this month's choices. About The Author.

See our privacy policy. A lot or a little? The parents' guide to what's in this movie. Stands out for positive messages. Educational Value. Positive Messages. Positive Role Models. Judd Travers drinks beer and chews tobacco. What parents need to know Parents need to know that Phyllis Reynolds Naylor's Shiloh , the story of a boy's love for an abused beagle, is thrilling and moving, and it will make kids think.

Continue reading Show less. Stay up to date on new reviews. Get full reviews, ratings, and advice delivered weekly to your inbox. User Reviews Parents say Kids say. Adult Written by Mrs. Teacher February 26, Great book. I have read this book many different years with groups of fourth graders. I wanted to write a review after reading the others submitted so far. Judd is shown Continue reading. Report this review.

Parent Written by J T. March 9, Language The review from Common Sense Media doesn't mention that there is cussing in this children's book. Not okay. Teen, 13 years old Written by sqwert90 October 7, Kid, 11 years old April 14, I remember when we read this book in 3rd grade! What's the story? As his eyes were opened to true good and evil, Shiloh became more than a story of a boy and his dog.

Leaving room for you to come up with your own answers, Phyllis Reynolds Naylor's prose asks if it's ever okay to omit part of the truth, right and wrong, what to do when the right thing to do is also the wrong thing to do, and more.

At least 12 years later, and the ending of the first book in The Shiloh Quartet still remains one of the most magically down to earth things I have ever read. Shiloh deserves to be howled about from the rooftops. Mar 21, Heather rated it it was ok Shelves: young-adult. I happened to be subbing for a 5th grade class that was reading this book, and I decided to see what it was about.

I'm not a huge fan of boy-and-his-dog stories, but I can appreciate them for the way they do speak to young boys. However, Shiloh would not be one I would recommend. I know. It's a Newberry Winner! It's got talk of Jesus in it! It's about wrestling with moral issues! It's about doggie love! First, Newberry awards are sometimes more of a warning signal than a badge of honor, sadly I happened to be subbing for a 5th grade class that was reading this book, and I decided to see what it was about.

First, Newberry awards are sometimes more of a warning signal than a badge of honor, sadly. While the winners may be well-written, they also often are subtle or not-so-subtle vehicles for popular agendas. They are rarely timeless classics, although that shiny gold seal automatically launches them into that category. I can only imagine that those looking for Christian-friendly children's books have embraced this one, but in truth its the religious aspects are terribly shallow.

A moralistic episode between the main character and his mother along the lines of "I can't make you confess, but remember that Jesus knows if you lied and it makes Him sad. They don't appear to pray together, read the Bible, even go to church.

Other references to Jesus include the boy, Marty, using "Jesus strike me blind" to strengthen a promise and narrating to us that, though his mother doesn't like that kind of talk, his grandmother always used it. Moreover, the ethical wrestling in Shiloh is carefully planned so that there is really no contest at all.

Obviously, the central question is whether it is okay to lie in order to protect someone helpless the dog, in this case. This tension comes up again and again in Marty's narrative. He thinks it to himself and asks his parents about it and sees some of the consequences of his lying, and yet. And yet there is never any real question. The deck is stacked in such a way that we have to agree that of course he must lie under these circumstances.

Any possible third options are effectively squashed: He can't earn the money fast enough to buy the dog. He can't trust the authorities to protect the dog. He can't reason with the abusive owner of the dog.

And so on and on. Meanwhile, rather than making Marty actually struggle and decide to suffer the consequences for his actions, the story resolves itself through two deus ex machina or rather canis ex machina and cervus ex machina events. His lies bring a little temporary discomfort, but no real, difficult consequences, and he ends up getting everything his way anyway. Thus, for all its seeming high regard for morality, this story becomes merely a crafty lesson in situational ethics.

And in great part, it is effective in teaching this lesson because of the perfect puppy at its center. Shiloh has no flaws. He is obedient, restrained, affectionate, long-suffering. Who could help loving such a dog? Not only Marty but also his more sensible parents cannot help themselves and will break their own principles for the sake of the little beagle at the heart of it all.

For the slightly discerning reader, it is an almost insufferable appeal to pathos. For the elementary school child reading such a book, its emotional appeal will almost certainly work its magic to override any compunctions.

In the end, Shiloh , for all its surface morality, has almost nothing to contribute to building a child's character. There are better boy-and-his-dog stories to offer children. Give them something like Where the Red Fern Grows if you want them to think about themes of integrity, hard work, and the joy and pain that come along with love.

View 1 comment. Jun 01, Chris Thompson rated it it was amazing. Shiloh is a simple story about a boy who falls in love with an abused dog, and a dog who returns his affection. Anybody who has ever gotten a puppy as a child will be able to relate to the adoration Marty shows the dog he names Shiloh. While this is a story for young children, its themes and ethical dilemmas are much more sophisticated than some books written for adults.

Naylor asks some very interesting questions for parents to discuss with their kids, and even one another, questions that don't Shiloh is a simple story about a boy who falls in love with an abused dog, and a dog who returns his affection. Naylor asks some very interesting questions for parents to discuss with their kids, and even one another, questions that don't necessarily have a right or wrong answer.

Marty comes across a distressed young dog one day, and it follows him home. His parents recognize it as Judd's new hunting dog. Judd has a reputation for mistreating his animals, and for this reason Marty wants to keep the dog, who he names Shiloh, but his parents tell him he can't. It belongs to Judd and it's not anybody's business what Judd does with his property.

This kind of logic does not persuade Marty. Shiloh flees his master yet again, and this time Marty keeps him a secret from his family. He builds a makeshift pen in their expansive yard, hidden from view, and keeps Shiloh there. He sneaks food every night, eating less of his own dinner so Shiloh can have something to eat.

It takes a toll on Marty to continue lying to his parents, but he decides it's in Shiloh's best interest to keep quiet. Even his two sisters are becoming curious about where he sneaks off to. Judd stops by one night asking about his new hunting dog and he seems to suspect that Marty's hiding something. A showdown between Judd and Marty is inevitable.

Shiloh won the Newbery Award, spawned two sequels, and was made into a movie, a testament to its quality and its popularity. This is a great book for younger readers. They will love it because of the friendship between Marty and Shiloh, and parents will love it because it has good values and poses some excellent questions for kids, and adults, to ponder. In considering his own moral code, Marty realizes that it is wrong to lie and to steal, but he feels a stronger obligation to keep a dog from returning to its abusive owner.

What makes this conflict so interesting is that adults would likely consider it much differently than children. Adults, whose moral values are more logical and place a stronger foundation on property, would say Marty should mind his own business.

If there was proof of extreme abuse or neglect, the law could step in, but a dog fearful of its owner is not proof. At least not to an adult. To a child like Marty, the proof is in the animal's eyes.

He couldn't forgive himself for returning an innocent animal to someone who will not treat it with love. Surprisingly, Judd, is very well-developed for being the villain of a young adult novel.

Many novels or movies aimed at kids have one-dimensional or very silly villains, but Judd is much more human. I believe many of us have known someone like Judd. How Naylor resolves the conflict between Judd and Marty makes sense, and it sends a positive message.

In making her villain human, she shows that though there are bad people in the world, things aren't simply black and white. You don't have to fight fire with fire. In fact, it is more effective to stand by your principles and stand up to people like Judd. Shiloh isn't just a novel about a boy who falls in love with a dog; it is about a boy who learns to be brave.

May 13, Liza Fireman rated it really liked it Shelves: books , ebook , read-from-shelf. There is something wonderful in children's books.

My daughter and I took as a project to go through Newberry Award winners, and many of them are really great, this one included. Marty Preston saves his dog from an abusive owner. Shiloh actually belongs to Judd Travers who drinks too much and has a gun. Marty loves the dog deeply and gets in trouble trying to care for him. Marty secrets are becoming larger: A lie. That's a flat-out lie. Funny how one lie leads to another and before you know it, you There is something wonderful in children's books.

Funny how one lie leads to another and before you know it, your whole life can be a lie. His love to the dog is heartwarming, and the fear of Judd who Marty encounters a lot does not prevent from Marty to still put the dog as top priority.

He says: If Jesus ever comes back to earth again, I'm thinking, he'll come as a dog, because there isn't anything as humble or patient or loving or loyal as the dog I have in my arms right now. That is not a small thing when Jesus appears in the book quite a lot: "may Jesus make you blind.

Ma says Jesus don't go around making anyone blind, but Grandma Preston always used it as a warning and she went to church Sunday morning and evening both. Shiloh won the Newberry Award for Literature, and rightfully so. Almost 4. Newbery Medal: Much more than a story about a boy and his dog Shiloh is a story of compassion, determination and struggling with stretching the truth to accomplish a goal that is character worthy. Is omitting information the same as lying, especially if it prevents abuse?

Marty Preston, 11, finds a beagle in the woods behind his house one day. When he realizes it belongs to Judd Travers, his heart drops because he knows Judd is mean and abusive to his animals.

When the dog comes back the s Newbery Medal: Much more than a story about a boy and his dog When the dog comes back the second time, Marty secretly hides him. The outcome isn't all he expected when the dog, he has now named Shiloh, is injured by a bigger dog Marty and his family slowly grow to love the gentle, friendly dog and Marty is prepared to do just about anything to keep him, to buy him, and to care for him.